The Broken Inn

Great, hometown, pub/bar/hangout. Friendly faces, unique/historic decor, good food, great soft seve, and the best pour of wine! Also has a lot of NY state beers on tap. I have ate dinners & snacks there many times. Brunches are only Saturday & Sunday, but they are so good. The 3 egg, eggs Benedict on a Portuguese rolls is 🤤. They have a specials menu & the creamiest soft serve too.

I found this to be an inviting, pleasant new eatery in my neighborhood. The decor has stories from where it all originated from various parts of the country. The menu small, but perfect, not remotely overwhelming. I've never seen a bigger sandwich, fresh bread from a local bakery, perfectly shaved Turkey, the cole slaw was excellent, a hint of pineapple. We loved it, will be going back time and time again. Highly recommend!!

I hate leaving a bad review because the server was very nice but I was so disappointed. Came here with my husband. We don’t typically eat a lot, just enjoy trying new places. We almost always split an app then split an entree. Apparently that is a big no no here. It actually says right on the menu you will be charged more than the cost of an entree to split one as the server will lose out on a tip. As a server myself, I can tell you that a bigger check does not mean a bigger tip, and I am extremely generous when it comes to tipping, especially when I don’t order a whole lot. The food was also not very good. The boneless wings were gross and the fries tasted like pure oil. My 2 year old enjoyed her meal though.

Visited twice now. Food is hit and miss. Good first time, okay second time. Burger overcooked and seemed like it was cooked earlier in the day and held until ordered. Ran out of diet pepsi--how does that happen? Everything is overpriced. $9 for a pint of beer! And the goofy rule about splitting a meal carries an extra $20 charge has got to go along with the no credit cards accepted--its 2022, that's what people use. This place has good potential, but has work to do to keep from heading downhill.

What a delightful and delicious experience we had tonight! Wonderful ambiance, great service, comfortable table, and, best of all, excellent food. Recommend you take a look at the menu before going as menu is limited.